A Mistake is shortlisted for the Ockham New Zealand Book Awards Jann Medlicott Acorn Prize for Fiction.
One of my favourite novels from 2019, A Mistake is a clipped and refined novel from Wellington-based writer Carl Shuker who is excellent at illustrating the nuances of place, character and plot. Slim and concise, it’s neatly written and tightly wound. I loved Shuker’s 2006 novel The Lazy Boys. A white-knuckled, striking and believable depiction of toxic masculinity and scarfie culture in Dunedin, it was a thrilling, brutal and unforgettable read. I’ll pick up anything with his name on it.
Written in a diagnostic style, A Mistake is based around a woman named Elizabeth Taylor, who at 42 is the youngest and only woman consultant general surgeon at Wellington Hospital. With a pristine track record, she’s extremely talented, driven and committed to her craft and patients. A stickler for detail, Elizabeth is very process-focused. An intense scene early in A Mistake sees her leading her team in theatre for what should be fairly routine procedure. Her background music of choice is the punishingly pulverising and exhilarating ‘Angel of Death’ by thrash metal band Slayer. So it’s all very heightened and the tension is palpable. But then something goes terribly wrong. And people want answers as the implications for Elizabeth and the people around her escalate.
There are so many interesting issues at play, here. A Mistake examines process and burnout, but also the complexities and frailties around human error. Shuker intersperses chapters with pieces about the American Challenger space shuttle disaster in 1986 which broke apart 73 seconds into flight killing all seven crew members. The Challenger was troubled from the outset, and these interesting interjections punctuate the tension here.
Shuker plainly lays it all out: if you want to understand the implications of massive systems failure determined months in advance but happening in microseconds in front of you as you try to cope in real time, The Challenger timeline is the first thing you might read.
Elizabeth is co-writing a paper examining the public reportage of surgical outcomes for the Royal London Journal of Medicine. Meanwhile, at the hospital, there’s a new reporting system being introduced around big data. The atmosphere around this is increasingly paranoid and on edge. A Mistake is set in a strikingly vivid and recognisable Wellington, with additional scenes in Auckland and an uncomfortable conference in Queenstown.
I love the way Shuker has written this character. Elizabeth Taylor has a fixed smile, like a mask. All muscle and no feeling. She’s up for 27 hours straight and is so constipated that she hasn’t used the toilet in two days. But, she observes, that is quite useful for long stints in the operating theatre.
Elizabeth Taylor is an alluring and fascinating character. I want to know why Shuker called her Elizabeth Taylor! The obvious comparison is to the famous iconic raven-haired, violet-eyed film star. But beyond that, her name actually immediately made me think of that great one-of-a-kind dystopian writer J.G. Ballard. In Ballard’s seminal 1973 novel Crash, the character Vaughan has an intense fantasy about dying in a car crash with Elizabeth Taylor. A far-fetched connection? Maybe, but both books share a similar clinical coolness, inner weirdness and steelyness.
A Mistake is a razor sharp and compelling novel from a singular, sophisticated literary voice in contemporary New Zealand fiction.
More information about the Ockham New Zealand Book Awards can be found here.
